We replayed 9,711 historical SEC-catalyst picks through three exit rules on identical entries. The result is not close: a trailing stop beat fixed profit targets on net return and captured 6Γ more of the big runners β the exact tail that pays for an aggressive book.
Catalyst returns follow a power law. Most picks go nowhere; a handful double. An aggressive portfolio lives or dies on how much of those doublings it actually keeps. So the sharpest test isn't the average trade β it's runner capture: of the picks that ran at least +30% intraday, how much did each exit rule bank?
| Fixed (current) | Stop β10%. Sell half at +12%, the rest at +24% or the stop. This is what today's trade frames publish β and it sells the 100% runner at the first rung. |
| Trailing | A stop that ratchets up 2.5ΓATR below the running high and never comes back down. Gives the runner room to breathe; exits only when the move genuinely reverses. |
| Hybrid | Half off at +12%, the rest trails β tightening as the runner extends. A middle path: banks something early, still rides the tail. |
The result is real, but confidence is earned by naming what the study can't tell you. Two caveats do most of the work:
Every Catalyst Edge pick is logged with its outcome β hits and misses. Watch the exit policy get better in public, then decide for yourself.
See the track record βCatalyst Edge is a research tool, not an investment adviser, and nothing here is financial advice or a recommendation to buy or sell any security. Backtested and simulated results are hypothetical, do not represent actual trading, and have inherent limitations β past performance does not guarantee future results. Prices used are delayed. You are responsible for your own decisions and risk.
You are one page deep in a scanner that grades its own picks in public, wins and losses alike.
Review the methodology and limitations and the dated audit. An intraday price touch is not trading profit.
One payment, access for as long as we run the service. The free daily picks stay free β this is for people who want the full console. Not buying today? Get tomorrow's ranked list free β